PiXL News » Exam anxiety: a self audit for leaders 
Exam anxiety: a self audit for leaders blog heading. Includes a roundel of Jules Llewellyn, Head of Curriculum Assessment at PiXL. Main image features a thoughtful school leader.

Exam anxiety: a self audit for leaders 

7 minute read

How to use this audit 

Work through these 18 questions with your senior team before mocks, so there is still time to act before the summer series. The questions are adapted from the key questions for leaders in the PiXL Revision guide on exam anxiety. 

Follow the steps below to get the most out of the audit: 

  1. Complete it as a team. Bring together colleagues with responsibility for leadership, SEND and pastoral care, as each will notice different things. 
  2. Rate each question red (R), amber (A) or green (G) using the rating system below and note the evidence behind your rating. 
  3. Keep all evidence at cohort or group level. Do not record named students in this document. 
  4. Choose a small number of red or amber items to prioritise before mocks and record them in the action plan at the end. 
  5. Revisit the audit after mocks, to review what worked and reset your priorities before the summer series. 
RatingWhat it means 
Red (R) Not in place, or left to chance. 
Amber (A) Happening in places, but not consistent across the school. 
Green (G) Embedded, consistent and understood by all staff. 

Why this matters before mocks 

Between 12% and 18% of secondary students experience high levels of test anxiety. That is four or five students in every class of 30 (Putwain and Daly, 2014).

  • It costs grades. Students with high levels of test anxiety perform below what their knowledge would allow, even when ability is taken into account (Ofqual, 2020). 
  • Preparation alone is not enough. 72% of UK students report feeling anxious even when well prepared for a test, against 56% globally (OECD, 2015). 
  • Mocks are a turning point. A poorly handled mock result can entrench negative self-belief at exactly the moment revision needs to accelerate. 
  • The anxious students are not always visible. Boys are more likely to cope through avoidance, so their anxiety can be harder to spot (Ofqual, 2020). 

A bit of pressure helps students who see it as a challenge they can meet. For students who see it as a threat, the same pressure produces anxiety, not motivation (Putwain, 2024).

Section A: understanding the picture in your school 

Schools that wait for students to show distress will miss many of the most anxious, particularly boys, who are more likely to cope through avoidance (Ofqual, 2020). 

# Question What green could look like Rating Evidence and notes 
1Do you know which students are most at risk of exam anxiety, and do you have a structured way to identify them before the exam period? A short questionnaire in Year 9 or early Year 10 identifies who needs targeted support, well before exams .
2Do you look for patterns in your data by gender, SEND, year group, subject or socioeconomic background? Leaders know where anxiety is concentrated, including groups less likely to disclose it. 
3When students appear disengaged or paralysed in an assessment, do staff recognise this may be a freeze response rather than a lack of effort or ability? Staff understand that going blank is a physiological state and respond with support, not sanctions. 

Section B: language and culture 

Warnings about the consequences of failure, such as “these results will follow you for life” are used in good faith, but they raise anxiety in the students who are already most vulnerable (Putwain and Symes, 2014).

# Question What green could look like Rating Evidence and notes 
4Are the messages students receive about exams, from teachers, displays, assemblies and results events, mainly threat based or challenge based?Messages are honest about stakes and focus on what students can do to perform at their best
5Do staff warn students about the consequences of failure to motivate them, either directly or through their tone? Staff understand that warnings about failure increase anxiety without increasing effective effort and use a shared vocabulary instead. 
6Does your approach to mock exams and results days reduce or amplify anxiety? Mock results are returned through a consistent process, with context and support available straight away. 
7Do students measure progress against their own previous best, rather than against each other? Students set personal best goals and are not ranked or compared publicly. 

Section C: staff pressure and wellbeing 

Around 70% of teachers say their own stress sometimes affects how they interact with students (Hutchings, 2015). Pressure passed down from leaders reaching the classroom. 

# Question What green could look like Rating Evidence and notes 
8Do leaders absorb accountability pressure in exam season, rather than passing it on to staff? Leaders deliberately absorb pressure rather than pass it on, and data conversations in exam season focus on support.
9Do leaders recognise that protecting staff from exam pressure also protects students?Staff wellbeing is planned into the exam season calendar as part of the strategy for student outcomes. 

Section D: curriculum and preparation 

Preparedness is one of the most reliable buffers against anxiety. The strongest school programmes combine teaching students about anxiety, skill building, and cognitive strategies (Putwain et al., 2014). 

# Question What green could look like Rating Evidence and notes 
10Are students explicitly taught what exam anxiety is, why it happens, and what they can do about it? Every student learns this through PSHE, tutor time or assemblies, so going blank is understood rather than feared.
11Are students taught study skills and exam techniques alongside subject content? Students practice managing time under pressure and approaching questions they find difficult. 
12Are students familiar with formal exam conditions before Year 10 or 11? Students practice sitting in rows, in silence and under time pressure, in low-stakes assessments before Year 10.
13Is exam preparation, including its emotional side, built into the curriculum rather than added at the end of Year 11?Exam preparation is sequenced across key stages, not bolted on in the final months.

Section E: specific interventions 

These are low cost and evidence backed. Writing about worries just before a high-stakes assessment improves performance (Ramirez and Beilock, 2011), and a three-minute task needs no specialist resource. 

# Question What green could look like Rating Evidence and notes
14Are students explicitly taught breathing and relaxation techniques? All students learn and practice these techniques regularly, for example in tutor time. 
15Do students get a few minutes to write about their worries just before high-stakes assessments? A short, private writing task is part of the routine just before mocks and exams. 
16Are access arrangements identified early for eligible students, or only in the final months before exams? Eligible students are identified proactively, well before Year 11. 
17Is the pre-exam wait, when students gather and compare revision, actively managed? A calm, structured routine replaces last minute comparison outside the exam room. 

Section F: parents and families 

Monitoring revision time, criticising effort and making results the centre of family conversation all increase anxiety (Ofqual, 2020). 

# Question What green could look like Rating Evidence and notes 
18Are parents given clear, specific guidance on supporting their child through exams in ways that reduce pressure, including what not to say?Families receive practical guidance before mocks, covering helpful language and what to avoid. 

Action plan: priorities before mocks 

Choose a small number of red or amber items to prioritise. Fewer actions done well will do more than many started at once. You don’t need to fill every row. 

Priority QuestionAction Lead By when How we will know it has worked 
1
2
3
4
5

PiXL members can find more revision support on the PiXL Portal. 

Not a PiXL member? Find out more.