Read time 7 minutes
Spot the signs of death by meeting
I have sat in more meetings than I could ever count. I have been in meetings that lifted me and meetings that drained me. I suspect you have too.
We all know the ones. The agenda is twelve items long and we get through four. The same two voices fill the room. Someone is answering emails under the table. A decision we thought we made last month comes back again, because nobody wrote it down. So much has happened in the day that we suffer from metaphorical whiplash, turning our attention quickly from this to that.
Patrick Lencioni called it Death by Meeting, and the phrase stuck because it is so recognisable. In schools, where time is the most precious thing we have, it matters even more. Every hour a senior team spends in an unproductive meeting is an hour wasted. As guardians of people’s time, we should see wasting it as one of the greatest offences.
So I want to be honest: meetings are hard. They ask a group of busy, passionate people to think together, listen well and agree a way forward, often at the end of a long day. That is not easy, and it is not anyone’s fault when it goes wrong. But it can be so much better.
Tackle the lack of clarity
The longer I lead, the more convinced I am that most meetings fail for one reason: we are not clear. Not clear about why we are there, what kind of conversation we are having, how we want to behave, or who gets to decide.
Here is the problem that I often have: trying to do everything in one meeting. We explore a brand new idea, firefight this week’s problems, make a big decision and review last term, all in the same hour. Of course it feels messy. We are asking people to switch between completely different ways of thinking without telling them.
Clarity is kind. When people know what to expect, they can prepare, contribute and relax into the conversation. When they don’t, they guard, they talk over each other, or they go quiet. The answer is not more meetings or fewer meetings. It is clearer ones, with a shared contract for how we will work together.
Lead better meetings with five practical tips
1. Split your meetings by purpose
Stop asking one meeting to do everything. Give each meeting one job and name it in the diary, so everyone knows what kind of thinking to bring. With senior teams I suggest four types:
- Upstream: step out of firefighting to find the root causes of the problems that keep coming back year on year.
- Rumble: explore a new idea openly, with curious questions and no decision on the day, allowing time to question a concept and think around a potential decision.
- Action-focused: quick-fire, day-to-day items, each with an owner and a due date.
- After-action review: learn from an event, a project or a term, so we keep what worked and improve what did not. Learning, not blame.
2. Agree how you’ll behave
Most agendas tell us what we will discuss. Very few tell us how we will treat each other while we discuss it. Agree that up front and don’t be scared to do it. No interrupting. Hands up and the chair invites. Curious questions only, not leading ones. No laptops, no distractions. It sounds simple, but when a team agrees these together, the room feels different because we all know what to expect.
3. Give people time to think
The best thinking rarely happens on the spot. Send pre-reading a week ahead and ask for questions in advance. If people haven’t read it, try Golden Silence: ten minutes of reading in the room, so everyone starts on the same page. Go round in turn so every voice is heard, and ask the empty chair question: who is not here whose voice needs to be heard? For bigger decisions, build in a cool-down period and agree when you will come back to decide. Remember, those who are more introverted may not have their best idea in the room, but afterwards following reflection. Let’s not fall for the extrovert ideal where we listen to those who sound the most vocal and confident.
4. Be clear about who decides
So much frustration comes from people not knowing whether they have a voice or a vote. Say it plainly at the start. Then be clear about the freedom someone has to act. Brighouse and Woods’ nine levels of delegation are brilliant for this, running from give me the facts and I will decide to take action, no further communication needed. Name the level when you hand something over, and watch the confusion fall away.
The nine levels are:
- Look into this problem. Give me all the facts. I will decide what to do.
- Let me know the options available, with the pros and cons of each. I will decide what to select.
- Let me know the criteria for your recommendation, which alternatives you have identified and which one appears best to you, with any risk identified. I will make the decision.
- Recommend a course of action for my approval.
- Let me know what you intend to do. Delay action until I approve.
- Let me know what you intend to do. Do it unless I say not to.
- Take action. Let me know what you did. Let me know how it turns out.
- Take action. Communicate with me only if action is unsuccessful.
- Take action. No further communication with me is necessary.
5. Chair well and close the loop
The rules only work if someone holds them, kindly and firmly. Agree who chairs and give them permission to keep to time and steer the conversation back. Before anyone leaves, read back the actions and decisions. Then start the next meeting with last week’s actions. A simple red, amber, green tracker makes progress visible, and gives you something to celebrate as items turn green.
Pick one meeting
I am not asking you to overhaul every meeting by Monday. I am asking you to start one conversation or do one thing differently.
At your next senior team meeting, take fifteen minutes and ask your team three questions:
- Which of our meetings need the most rules to keep them productive and healthy?
- What gets in the way of our meetings being even better?
- When we leave a meeting thinking “that was a great meeting”, what was happening in the room?
Then pick one meeting, agree its purpose and contract the rules together, and try it for half a term. Review it honestly, keep what works, and change what doesn’t.
Great meetings don’t happen by accident. They happen by design, and by leaders who choose clarity over habit. Our time, and our people’s time, is too precious to spend any other way.
Read further
These are the books that have shaped my thinking on meetings:
- Time to Think by Nancy Kline: listening without interruption and the quality of attention.
- Death by Meeting by Patrick Lencioni: splitting meetings by purpose.
- Dare to Lead by Brené Brown: being clear about what done looks like.
- Upstream by Dan Heath: solving problems before they happen.
- Turn the Ship Around! by L. David Marquet: “I intend to” and learning after action.
- The Art of Gathering by Priya Parker: a clear purpose for every gathering.
PiXL members, for more leadership content, register for our next Stronger Leaders session.
Not a PiXL member? Find out more.



