Category: Compassionomics

  • From “that sounds like a good idea” to how a whole school runs

    From “that sounds like a good idea” to how a whole school runs

    Forty Seconds at Primrose Hill: Part 4 of 4. The leader’s view.

    Emma Mignaud has been head teacher at Primrose Hill Church of England Primary Academy since 2019. By her own admission, she already had a good school before any of this, with a positive previous inspection and a settled, supportive community. So, the question worth putting to a leader in that position is why she would change anything at all. Her answer explains how an idea from a hospital ended up running through a primary school in the Forest of Dean. 

    She first heard the word compassionomics at a Trust heads day, where Rachel Johnson from PiXL was speaking. The research, drawn from medicine, found that a 40-second compassionate conversation could measurably lower a patient’s anxiety. The same studies linked it to shorter hospital stays and to less pain after an operation. Emma’s reaction was immediate, and it tells you something about how she leads. “I thought, if it can do all of that for patients, it can have a huge impact with some of our children.”

    Maximum impact, lowest effort

    Emma’s direct about her own philosophy. “Maximum impact for lowest effort. Those are the things that tend to gain the most traction when you’re introducing them.” Compassionomics fitted exactly. It cost a teacher almost nothing to do, and the potential return was out of all proportion to that. 

    She knew the first objection would be time, so she met that head on. She opened the staff meeting after that heads day with a question. “Has anyone got a spare 40 seconds?” Of course they did. Only then did she explain what those seconds were for, and she connected it to the school’s reason for doing anything. “We always come back to the why,” she said. Emma is clear that it sharpened the relationship-building the school already believed in and gave it a tighter focus. 

    That targeting is the heart of it. Primrose Hill builds good relationships with every child, but Emma identified a group at risk of slipping through warmth that’s spread evenly across a room. “Some children are perhaps a little bit invisible in their day. They’re very well behaved, they’re compliant, but they don’t put themselves out there.” The strategy is a deliberate conversation, held every day, with those children, the ones who would never demand one. Everyone in the school, teachers, teaching assistants and the office staff, has one or two targeted children they make a beeline for. The teaching assistants, Emma notes, have become the biggest drivers of it, and have grown in confidence by seeing the difference they make. 

    The stone in the pond 

    Emma has an image for how it spreads. “Compassionomics is the stone that falls into the pond.” The targeted conversations are the stone, deliberate and daily. The ripple is everything that follows: adults having warm conversations with children who aren’t on anyone’s list, simply because the school has got better at it. The sharpest results show up in the targeted children, and the wider culture lifts with them. 

    The case studies she shared show both. One child in Year 4 was completing none of his home reading or times-tables practice. A teaching assistant held a daily 40-second conversation with him, generic at first, then gently focused, with a line that did the real work: “When I get home tonight I’m going to check the app to see you’ve been on it.” The child knew an adult was thinking about him after the school gates closed. Five minutes a day became a habit, the habit built, and he ended up standing in worship to collect a certificate for recalling every multiplication and division fact faster than any adult in the school. The knock-on reached his maths. A child who hadn’t been at age-related expectations was, a year later, working at greater depth. “Success breeds success,” Emma said, and she attributes the start of it to a conversation that cost under a minute. 

    Another of Emma’s targeted children was a boy who found friendships hard and could struggle to regulate his emotions. She took this one on herself and her way in was rocks. He was, in her words, a little obsessed with them, so the daily 40 seconds was mostly about rocks, to the point that he bought her a rock advent calendar at Christmas and she now calls herself an expert. The change showed at playtime. He’s no longer on the edge of things. He has a crowd around him, building rock houses and telling them about what he has found on the playground. Behaviour incidents dropped, his attendance improved, and Emma puts it down to those few seconds a day. 

    She’s just as deliberate about parents, and just as careful. One mother was disengaged and kept her son at arm’s length from school. Emma didn’t march toward her, knowing a head walking straight at you can feel like a summons. Instead, she positioned herself near the gate, sometimes pretending to pick up a piece of litter, then stood and walked in alongside her with an easy, generic chat. On the days they didn’t speak, Emma sent a warm message home about something good her son had done. The mother started smiling before she saw her. The boy’s attendance went from 80 per cent to 97 per cent. “She felt that she belonged to the community of our school,” Emma said, “and that was really powerful, for her and for us.”

    How you measure 40 seconds 

    Asked how a leader measures something this small, Emma names both halves. There’s hard data, the attendance figures, the assessment scores and the targeted children climbing. And there’s soft data which she values just as much. “The children who are smiling, the feeling you get when you walk around. If I’m off site for a couple of days, the children come straight up to me when I’m back. They feel like they’ve missed me.” For Emma the belonging runs both ways: “It’s not just that they belong here. They belong, and I belong as well.”

    What PiXL gave her 

    Emma is exact about what PiXL gave her, and it’s worth spelling out, because it‘s easy to assume the wrong thing. The network did the background reading for her. “They do the donkey work,” she said, condensing research she would never have had time to wade through, including work like compassionomics that comes from outside education altogether. That last part matters to her. Education, she says, can become insular, and some of the best ideas come from looking beyond it. Alongside the research, PiXL gave her specialists she can book a surgery with for niche problems, and a group of other leaders who have walked the walk and aren’t her bosses, which counts for a lot in a role she describes as isolating. The approach itself she kept in her own hands. “It’s not ‘you must do it like this,’” she said. “It’s ‘this is an idea, fit it to your school.’” It worked because it was moulded to Primrose Hill, by the people who know Primrose Hill. 

    Her advice to a head sitting on the fence about any of it is the plainest thing she said. “Do it. You will get some of your life back. You’ll give yourself permission to slow down and think strategically about your school.” 

    When asked to sum it up in a sentence, after a year of watching it work, she said: “Compassionomics is low effort and has maximum impact.” 

    It started as an idea from a hospital, passed on at a heads day. A year later it’s simply how Primrose Hill works, and the head who introduced it will tell you it cost almost nothing. 

    This completes the four-part Forty Seconds series. Primrose Hill C of E Primary Academy is a PiXL member school in the Forest of Dean. They first heard about compassionomics through PiXL. 

    Further reading 

    Trzeciak, S. and Mazzarelli, A. (2019) Compassionomics: The Revolutionary Scientific Evidence That Caring Makes a Difference. Studer Group Publishing.

  • “I wasn’t entirely sold.” A teacher on the 40 seconds that changed his classroom

    “I wasn’t entirely sold.” A teacher on the 40 seconds that changed his classroom

    Forty Seconds at Primrose Hill: Part 3 of 4. The teacher’s view. 

    Jake Parsons has taught at Primrose Hill for the whole of his career, six years, starting in Reception and now working in Year 5, where he says he has found his niche. He’s exactly the kind of teacher a new initiative must win over, because he’s honest about the first thing every teacher thinks when a new initiative arrives.  

    “When I first heard about compassionomics,” he told us, “I wasn’t entirely sold by the concept.” 

    It’s worth sitting with that admission, because the doubt he names is the one most teachers feel and rarely say out loud. Compassionomics, the body of medical research that found a 40-second compassionate conversation could measurably improve a patient’s outcomes, can sound to a stretched teacher like one more thing. Jake’s worry was the obvious one. “I’ve not got much time as it is, and now I need to try and fit these 40-second conversations in throughout the whole day. How am I going to fit them in?”

    Anyone who has stood in front of a class will recognise that thought. What matters is what moved him past it.

    Making the science usable

    Two things changed Jake’s mind, and the first was practical. He didn’t have to wade through the original research. “You didn’t have to go and read the whole scientific literature,” he said, “probably things that were above my pay grade anyway. PiXL condensed it, made it so we can understand it as teachers and teaching assistants, and it’s easy for us to implement.” The framework told him he didn’t have to reach every child at once. He could start with a few, stage it, and build. 

    The second thing was the realisation that he was half doing it already, just without the intent. “As teachers we do it in the first place, but it doesn’t have that intention behind it of ‘I want to find out more, I want to care and nurture just a little bit more.’” The shift was from asking children about their weekend in general, to choosing a child, listening properly, holding the detail, and following it up days later. “How was that all-inclusive Chinese you went for?” The child feels valued, he said, because the question proves you were really listening the first time. 

    His own definition, offered for any teacher who has never heard the term, is worth keeping. Compassionomics, he said, is “a direct approach to caring for the children, through conversation, through warmth and nurturing, through ensuring that all the children feel heard and listened to.” Then the line that identifies the real problem it solves: “So often as a teacher we talk and we don’t listen.” 

    There’s a nice tension in doing this well. Done right, the children shouldn’t notice it’s a strategy at all. Jake says it becomes “just what happens,” and then, every so often, he watches one of them almost catch him at it. “You can see the light-bulb moment, where they go, oh, he’s doing something here, he’s asking how my grandmother is after her hip operation.” Part 1 of this series rests on the fact that the children can’t name what the school is doing. This is the same fact, seen from the front of the room.

    The tally chart 

    Jake’s first focus child had struggled with attendance. Late every day, falling behind before he sat down, walking in already braced for the feeling of catching up. Jake started a daily conversation and, with the child, kept a tally of the mornings he arrived on time. They marked it off together, day after day. “He went from turning up late every single day for a whole term to being on time and there every single day.” The arithmetic of that is striking. A child who was losing the start of every lesson, brought back into the room by a conversation that cost under a minute. And once he was in the room, Jake watched the rest follow. The boy stopped carrying the stress of being behind, and his learning lifted with him. 

    The harder story was a boy who joined mid-year, having been excluded more than once elsewhere. Jake is candid about the red flag he felt reading the paperwork, with a settled, hard-working classroom he didn’t want disturbed. So, the team did the opposite of brace for trouble. “We made a really conscientious effort of going out of our way to really understand him as a person, to find out what makes him tick.” It turned out he had a good sense of humour, and that a light touch in a tense moment could defuse it before it escalated. “Since he joined, we’ve had no behaviour problems, and his work has improved significantly,” Jake said, from at-risk on attainment to working at age-related or better across the board. He’s careful to share the credit, naming the teaching assistants who bought into it. The point he keeps making is that the conversation only works if the caring is real before the question is asked. 

    The same team 

    Asked for the parent relationship that had changed most, Jake didn’t reach for a quick win. He described a mum whose son’s attendance was poor, and who, rather than bring him in late, would often keep him off without telling the school why. There was no chasing her with policy. Instead, the school had what Jake calls “candid conversations” and “compassionate conversations,” until something gave. “We made sure she realised that we’re on the same team here,” he said, “that behind that compassion is that we both want the best for her child.” Now she tells them straight away if there’s a problem, and she knows the door is always open. His way of putting it holds the whole strategy in a line: “What she wants and what we want is exactly the same.” 

    The mechanism is what should interest a leader. A short, repeated, genuine conversation changed how a hard-to-reach adult behaved, and the child’s attendance moved with it. The parents in Part 2 of this series describe what that warmth feels like from their side of the gate. Here’s the teacher describing how it gets built.

    Bravery, and the why 

    There’s a quieter strand in Jake’s account, and it’s about courage, one of the school’s values. He shows what that word means in practice, which hits harder than any poster on a wall. He teaches a class of ten-year-old boys reaching the age where feelings go underground. One told him, in a lesson on emotions, that his dad had said sadness should be pushed down. Jake saw the moment for what it was and gently turned it over. “We want people who know it’s brave to show empathy, to be nurturing and caring. That takes bravery.” Getting boys who would rather not talk to talk is now, he says, one of the things he watches for most. 

    The care turned out to travel in both directions. Jake noticed behaviour settle right across the classroom, “because they care for you as you care for them, it’s reciprocated in both ways.” And it didn’t stay between him and the children. The staff have started doing it with each other, and a session held without the head and deputy in the room, simply so people could talk openly, is the kind of thing Jake says wouldn’t have happened as easily before. He even admits, with a grin, that it has improved things at home. 

    His message to a teacher elsewhere who feels they have no time for this isn’t a slogan. It’s an instruction. “Make time. You can do it in those small moments throughout the day,” the walk to the lunch hall, the few minutes before the bell, the playground duty where you talk to a child who isn’t even in your class. Weave it in so it’s flexible rather than rigid, he says, and be honest about which children most need it. The rest happens as a by-product. 

    He ended on the line that, more than the data, explains why it works. “Between the times of nine and three, you are their parent. It’s your sole job to make sure they feel looked after, cared for, listened to and nurtured. The learning is a by-product of that.” 

    Final part: Emma Mignaud, the head teacher, on hearing about compassionomics at a PiXL trust heads day and turning “that sounds like a good idea” into how a whole school runs. Primrose Hill is a PiXL member school in the Forest of Dean. 

    Missed part 1 and part two? Check them out here: Part 1 (The student’s view), Part 2 (The parent’s view).

    Further reading 

    Trzeciak, S. and Mazzarelli, A. (2019) Compassionomics: The Revolutionary Scientific Evidence That Caring Makes a Difference. Studer Group Publishing.

  • The 40 seconds lands on the parents too 

    The 40 seconds lands on the parents too 

    Forty Seconds at Primrose Hill: Part 2 of 4. The parents’ view.

    There’s a version of this story that stops at the child. A teacher holds a short, warm, deliberate conversation with a pupil, the pupil feels seen, the pupil settles, the outcomes improve. That version is true, and Parts 3 and 4 of this series tell it from the inside. But the picture is bigger than that. The parents at Primrose Hill told us the rest. The 40 seconds doesn’t stop at the child. It catches the adult dropping them off, and it follows them into the rest of their day.  

    We spoke to a group of parents, and separately to a parent who’s also a school governor. We started with the morning, because the morning is often where the strain is and nobody pretended otherwise. As the governor put it, the school run “isn’t always sunshine and rainbows.” You have battled your child into a coat, battled the other cars for a space, and arrived carrying whatever the week has already done to you. 

    A reset at the gate 

    Every parent there could name the feeling of handing their child over and walking away lighter. “Happy in, happy out,” one mother called it. Another reached for “stress free”: “I know she’ll be okay.” A third described the tell that does it for her: “The first thing my kids say is ‘Bye, Mummy,’ and I know instantly they’ve happily gone in there.” 

    But the welcome isn’t only for the children. The governor described arriving frayed and finding the head teacher at the gate. “She’s really personable. She’s human.” A short chat, sometimes about nothing to do with school at all, sometimes about football, sometimes just an honest “I’ve had a rough morning, you can tell.” He called it “an opportunity to reset,” and then, with feeling, “the best social drug.” He goes back to the car, takes a breath, and starts the day on a different footing. One mother, who had worked late the night before, said the calm she picks up at drop-off is the calm she carries back to her desk: “It’ll affect my mood and make me start off on the right foot, because you know everybody’s happy here. And they care about you as well as the children.” 

    Another mother put the mechanism plainly. On a hard morning, she walks her son in rather than leaving him at the gate and quietly tells his teacher she has had a tricky start. They keep an extra eye on him, and she gets her day back. “I can be Claire,” she said, “as opposed to mum.” A teacher’s 40 seconds, spent on a child, handed a parent back her own name for the rest of the day. 

    They ask because they’re interested 

    What the parents kept circling was the difference between warmth that’s performed and warmth that’s real. “They’re not asking the question because they have to,” one said. “They’re asking because they’re interested.” Several mentioned bumping into staff in town and being stopped for a proper catch-up, including about children who left the school years ago. One described every door having an adult on it each morning, greeting children by name, “and that’s normal, that’s every day, that’s not ‘oh, the cameras are in.’” 

    The detail that came up in nearly every conversation was names. The head, they said, knows every child’s name, and a good deal more. “They also know what’s going on with the children at home or in school.” For these parents, that knowledge is what makes the trust possible. As the governor said, you’re handing over “my most prized possession” to people you didn’t know from Adam, and the school earns the right to that trust one short, genuine conversation at a time.

    What the governor sees 

    The parent who’s also a governor is worth coming back to, because the role hands him a second lens on the same school. Part of that job is to scrutinise it and ask the hard questions a parent never has to. So, it‘s worth noting the word he reaches for with the governor hat on was ambition. “There is a collective drive to be as ambitious as possible,” he said, “to achieve success, whatever that success looks like for the individual.” He pointed to the displays on the walls, the “we are artists, we are mathematicians” framing, and to the way the end goal is spelled out to the children from the start. Asked to describe the school in a few words, he chose “ambitious, driven, friendly and pragmatic.” 

    The obvious worry about any school built on compassion, that warmth comes at the cost of rigour. The parents kept closing that gap themselves. The behaviour policy is clear enough that families reinforce it at home, as one put it, “so there’s consistency.” At Primrose Hill the care and the high expectations pull in the same direction. 

    The same governor noticed where it all ends up. His daughter teaches him when she gets home. “No daddy, you wouldn’t remember how this worked, this is how we do it now,” and then she walks him through the method rather than the answer. What struck him was that she had taken on the reasoning, not the result alone. “It’s the why, and I’m a real believer that the why matters more than anything.” A short conversation at the gate is part of how a child comes to care enough to bring the lesson home and explain it to a parent who never asked. 

    The day it truly mattered 

    The clearest evidence came from a father remembering his son’s early days at the school, before the boy moved up to secondary. “We had tears at the gate. He’d lost a bit of confidence.” He described himself by the fence, trying to cajole a frightened child through the door, when a teacher came over. Not with a policy, but with a question: “Would you like me to help?” They sat, they talked, the boy heard there was nothing to worry about. “Within a few weeks he was back to normal and blossoming again.” His verdict on the staff who did it was simple. “They did a really good job there.” 

    That’s what 40 seconds buys, repeated daily and meant every time. A frightened child settled. A parent unclenched. A family that, years later, still talks about the school the way one mother did when we asked how she’d describe it to a newcomer: “My kids go to Primrose Hill. Which school are you looking at?”

    One parent took the longest view of all. She came to Primrose Hill herself, forty years ago, and now walks back through the same gates as an adult dropping off her own child. “Everything’s changed, but nothing’s changed,” she said. “The same ethos runs through the school as when I was here. It was always a happy school then. A well performing school. And to feel the same forty years later, that’s quite incredible.” In Part 1, a child imagined the school as somewhere safe enough to one day send children of her own. This is a parent who has done exactly that, forty years on. 

    The compassion was designed for the children. The parents are telling us it reached them too. 

    Next in the series: Jake Parsons, the Year 5 teacher who admits he “wasn’t entirely sold” when he first heard the idea, and what changed his mind. Then the head, Emma Mignot, on building a whole school around it. Primrose Hill is a PiXL member school in the Forest of Dean.

    Further reading 

    Trzeciak, S. and Mazzarelli, A. (2019) Compassionomics: The Revolutionary Scientific Evidence That Caring Makes a Difference. Studer Group Publishing. 

  • The children can’t name it. They can feel it. 

    The children can’t name it. They can feel it. 

    Forty Seconds at Primrose Hill: Part 1 of 4. The pupils’ view. 

    Ask a child at Primrose Hill C of E Primary Academy what “compassionomics” means and you’ll get a blank look. None of them have heard the word. None of them know that the adults around them have built a deliberate strategy out of a piece of medical research, or that a 40-second conversation is being held with intent, or that anyone, anywhere, is measuring whether it works. 

    What they can do is describe their school. And when you listen to how they describe it, you’re hearing proof that the strategy works. 

    We sat down with two groups of pupils and asked them simple things. What do you look forward to? How do you feel walking through the gates? Who do you tell when something exciting happens? What would you say to a child who doesn’t go here? Not one question mentioned compassion, or care, or relationships. We wanted to hear what they reached for on their own, without prompting. 

    They reached for trust. 

    A place you can trust 

    The word came up again and again, unprompted. One child explained why she always says hello to a teacher in the corridor: “I just want to make a bigger connection, to know I can trust them.” Another, asked what colour the school would be, chose a bright one, “because it shows that there’s somewhere that you can trust, somewhere you could send your children to when they grow up a little bit.” That’s a primary-age child describing the school as a place safe enough to one day hand over their own children. They’re not performing for a camera. They simply think this is what schools are. 

    Compassionomics

    When we asked what happens on a sad or quiet day, the answers were practical and certain. “I would share my problems with friends or teachers.” “I would tell my friends, then later I’d also tell my teachers.” One child described going in a little early so there was private time: “I take that personal time to tell stuff.” A child has worked out that the adults at the door have a few unhurried seconds for them before the day begins and has decided to spend those seconds on the things that matter most to them. That’s the 40 seconds, seen from the other side of it. 

    They didn’t pretend bad days never happen here. They were matter of fact that they do. What they were sure of was where a bad day goes when it arrives: to a friend first, then to a teacher. Knowing exactly where to take it isn’t something a child works out alone. They learn it from adults who have made themselves available before. 

    They have the words for how they feel 

    We also asked how they feel walking through the gates in the morning, and the answers stood out less for their warmth than for their range. Not just “happy.” One child said “curious,” because she and her friends would be wondering what the day’s lessons might bring. Another said “comfortable,” and explained it: “I feel happy because I know the friends that are going to be there, I feel comfortable.” A third said “excited, because I’m ready to know what we’re going to do today.” These are children who can name a feeling and tell you where it comes from. That fluency isn’t a given at this age. The teacher whose interview comes later in this series talks about the work involved in getting ten-year-old boys to talk about feelings at all. Here, the youngest children already have the words, because the adults around them use them every day.  

    They notice who notices them 

    The pupils were clear that the warmth isn’t rationed. When asked which grown-up always makes them laugh or smile, one child widened the question out before answering it: “all the teachers, because they never say mean things to you, but they always just make you smile.” Another described the school to an outsider as “warm and friendly, because it’s hard to run into someone who doesn’t say hello, especially the teachers.” 

    Mr Parsons, the Year 5 teacher, came up by name more than once. The children rated him not for his lessons but for something quieter. He has “a very good sense of humour,” one said, “and I think he can just understand you as well.” The children had noticed exactly that: a busy adult who, in the middle of a normal school day, takes the time to understand them. 

    Second family 

    The phrase that stayed with us came when we asked them to describe the school to someone who doesn’t go there. “I would describe our school as a second family,” one child said, “because everyone here is like friends with each other.” Another landed on “a trustful place where you could laugh and have a nice time.” A third went broad and happy: “a happy school, because all the people here are really happy and they’re really nice.” 

    There’s a temptation, reading these back, to find them sweet and leave it there. We would push the other way. These are children with no vocabulary for the thing being done to them, describing its exact effect with total accuracy. The adults set out to build a school where every child feels heard, valued and safe enough to bring their worries through the door. Ask the children, who have never seen the plan, and that’s the school they describe. 

    One last thread is worth pulling, because it’s the one that shows up in results. The very first answer we got, when we asked what the children look forward to, was this: “I look forward to learning new things because I want to know more about the world.” That’s a line about curiosity, not about feeling safe, though the two travel together. A child who isn’t spending the morning bracing has attention left over for the world beyond the classroom door. The security is what buys the curiosity. For a leader weighing whether 40 seconds is worth the bother, that is the entire argument, from belonging through to outcomes, made by a seven-year-old who had no idea they were making it. 

    The strategy is invisible to them. That’s how you know it has worked.

    Next in the series: the parents, who feel the same 40 seconds land on them at the gate. Then the teacher who started out unconvinced, and the head whose whole philosophy fits inside it. Primrose Hill is a PiXL member school in the Forest of Dean. They first heard about compassionomics through PiXL.  

    Further reading 

    Trzeciak, S. and Mazzarelli, A. (2019) Compassionomics: The Revolutionary Scientific Evidence That Caring Makes a Difference. Studer Group Publishing.